Reading
Dushyant's blog has prompted me to share some thoughts on the topic of the 52nd Filmfare award nominations.
Let's look at the nominations.
Best Film nominationsDhoom 2, Don, KANK, Krrish, Lage Raho Munnabhai, Rang De Basanti
First, whatever happened to the 5 nomination limit? Looks like next year's filmfare will have all movies released in the year nominated for the best movie award. Come on - you can't have D2, Krrish and KANK in the same category as LRM and RDB. And as Dushyant pointed out - where's Omkara and Gangster?
My picks (notice - 5 only - winners in bold): LRM,
RDB, Gangster, Omkara, Dor
Best Director NominationsKaran Johar (KANK), Rakesh Roshan (Krrish), Rakeysh Mehra (Rang De Basanti), Rajkumar Hirani (Lage Raho Munnabhai), Sanjay Gadhvi (Dhoom 2), Vishal Bhardwaj (Omkara)
Karan Johar for KANK? Did I read this right? KANK was one of the most poorly directed movies of 2007. I am a fan of Karan Johar's work but I'm not sure if KANK was the right one. Anurag Basu's fine work in Gangster was one of the finest I've seen.
My picks: Rakeysh Mehra, Rajkumar Hirani, Vishal Bharadwaj, Anurag Basu (Gangster), Nagesh Kukunoor (Dor)
Best Actor in a leading role (Male) nominationsAamir Khan (Rang De Basanti), Hrithik Roshan (Dhoom 2), Hrithik Roshan (Krrish), Sanjay Dutt (Lage Raho Munnabhai), Shahrukh Khan (Don), Shahrukh Khan (Kabhi Alvida Naa Kehna)
SRK in Don and KANK nominated as country's best in 2007? What is wrong with everyone? How about Shiney Ahuja in Gangster? I agree with the rest of the list.
My picks: Aamir Khan (RDB), Hrithik Roshan (Krrish), Shiney Ahuja (Gangster), Sanjay Dutt (LRM), Hrithik Roshan (Dhoom 2)
Best Actor in a leading role (Female) nominationsAishwarya Rai (Dhoom 2) Bipasha Basu (Corporate) Kajol (Fanaa) Kareena Kapoor (Omkara) Rani Mukerji (Kabhi Alvida Naa Kehna)
Aah - don't even get me started on why this list is wrong. What good did Rani and Kareena do to deserve the nominations? Also - why do we have 6 actors nominated and 5 actresses - don't we have talented actresses in the industry?
My picks: Aishwarya Rai (D2), Bipasha Basu (Corporate), Kajol (Fanaa), Kangana Raut (Gangster),
Ayesha Takia (Dor - has she looked prettier in any other movie?)
Best Actor in a supporting role (Male) nominationsAbhishek Bachchan (Kabhi Alvida Naa Kehna) Amitabh Bachchan (Kabhi Alvida Naa Kehna) John Abraham (Baabul) Kunal Kapoor (Rang De Basanti) Siddharth (Rang De Basanti)
Okay - give credit where its due (5 nominations only). I agree that both Kunal Kapoor and Siddharth should be nominated. Both Abhishek and Amitabh were the only saving grace in KANK. John Abraham had a good role and did do a good job but not better than Nana Patekar in Taxi # 9211.
My picks: Abhishek Bachchan (KANK), Amitabh Bachchan (KANK), Kunal Kapoor (RDB),
Siddharth (RDB), Nana Patekar (Taxi # 9211)
Best Actor in a supporting role (Female) nominationsKirron Kher (Rang De Basanti) Konkona Sen Sharma (Omkara) Priety Zinta (Kabhi Alvida Naa Kehna) Rekha (Krrish) Soha Ali Khan (Rang De Basanti)
After getting it right in the actor nominations - this one is messed up (again notice 5 nominations). Preity Zinta in KANK? Her acting was the worst I've seen - ever! Rekha didn't do anything dramatic in Krrish to deserve a nomination.
My picks: Kirron Kher (RDB),
Konkona Sen Sharma (Omkara), Soha Ali Khan (RDB), Alice Patten (RDB), Gul Panaag (Dor)
Best Actor in a comic role nominationsArshad Warsi (Lage Raho Munnabhai) Chunkey Pandey (Apna Sapna Money Money) Paresh Rawal (Phir Hera Pheri) Sharman Joshi (Golmaal) Tusshar Kapoor (Golmaal)
There are a lot of problems here (only 5 in this one as well). Phir Hera Pheri didn't really deserve a nomination. There have been better performances from Paresh Rawal this year. After the tons of comedies that released this year - this list is very very weak.
My picks: Arshad Warsi (LRM), Chunkey Pandey (ASMM),
Shreyas Talpade (Dor - the mimickry made me LOL), Paresh Rawal (Malamaal Weekly), Rajpal Yadav (Chup Chup Ke - the actor made you laugh all year long, he deserves a nomination)
Best Actor in a negative role nominationsBoman Irani (Lage Raho Munnabhai) Emraan Hashmi (Gangster) John Abraham (Zinda) Naseeruddin Shah (Krrish) Saif Ali Khan (Omkara)
Boman Irani was one of the lamest villains in LRM. And why did the list come down to 4 here - did we not have many villains in movies this year?
My picks: Boman Irani (Don), Emraan Hashmi (Gangster), John Abraham (Zinda), Boman Irani (Khosla Ka Ghosla),
Saif Ali Khan (Omkara)Best Music NominationsA R Rahman (Rang De Basanti) Himesh Reshammiya (Aksar) Jatin-Lalit (Fanaa) Pritam (Dhoom 2) Shankar-Ehsaan-Loy (Don) Shankar-Ehsaan-Loy (Kabhi Alvida Naa Kehna)
Himesh Reshammiya in Aksar - was the music any good? Pritam in D2 - the music sucked and well documented that it was a major letdown. I don't think KANK deserved a nomination as well.
My picks: A R Rahman (RDB), Pritam (Gangster - copy or no copy), SEL (Don), Shantanu Moitra (LRM), Vishal Bharadwaj (Omkara)
Best Playback MaleAtif Aslam (Bas Ek Pal), Himesh Reshammiya (Jhalak Dikhlaaja, Aksar), Shaan and Kailash Kher (Chaand Sifarish, Fanaa), Sonu Nigam (KANK - title), Zubin (Ya Ali - Gangster)
Where is Daler Mehndi for the year's biggest hit from RDB? and KK for Tu Hi Meri Shab from Gangster or Kya Mujhe Pyaar from Woh Lamhe. And how can we forget the wonderful job that Udit Narayan did for Khaike Paan?
My picks: Atif Aslam (Bas Ek Pal),
Zubin (Ya Ali - Gangster), Daler Mehndi (RDB - title), KK (Kya Mujhe Pyaar - Woh Lamhe), Udit Narayan (Khaike Paan - Don)
Best Playback FemaleAlka Yagnik (KANK - title), Shreya Ghoshal (Pal Pal - LRM), Sunidhi Chauhan (Aa aa ashiqui mein teri - 36 china town), Sunidhi Chauhan (Beedi Jalaile - Omkara), Sunidhi Chauhan (Soniye - Aksar)
Now agreed that these are popular awards - but some talents are better recognized for their capabilities and performances (some may only give such a performance once in a lifetime). There are a lot of songs that were absolutely breathtaking and definitely deserve a nomination for the best of 2007.
My picks: Sunidhi Chauhan (Beedi Jalaile - Omkara), Rekha Bharadwaj (Omkara - Namak Ishq Ka), Shreya Ghoshal (Pal Pal - LRM), Kavita Sheth (Mujhe Mat roko - Gangster - just listen to this one and you'd want to listen it over and over), Alisha Chinoy & Mahalaxmi (AAj Ki Raat - Don)
And finally - I'd be mad like hell if Saroj Khan doesn't win the best choreography for Khaike Paan. I watched the movie twice just for that performance.
I used to think Filmfare as India's Oscars and would defend it bad against all the SRK bashers. Trust me - I'm a fan of SRK, Karan Johar and the Yash Raj. However, one has to give credit to the talent when you spot one. People take being nominated for the Oscars as a serious credit to their performances. Ask Kate Winslet - who has been nominated so many times, never won but still thinks of it as an honor. You must have noticed the "Oscar Nominee XXXXX" during movie promos. With this list in the 52nd Filmfare, they've clearly removed themselves from the credible awards list. This is very discouraging to all the rising young stars and will continue giving rise to 15 other award functions throwing trophies out to anyone and everyone. Bollywood - if it has to compete on a global scale has to reward the right performances. Populist awards or not - there is no way you get away with a list like this. Shameful!